Katie Taylor vs Amanda Serrano: Last night, July 11, 2025, Madison Square Garden in New York City was electric as Katie Taylor and Amanda Serrano faced off in their third and likely final bout, headlining the first-ever all-women’s professional boxing card. This trilogy fight, steeped in history and rivalry, had fans on the edge of their seats. So, who won? Let’s dive into the details of this historic night, the outcome, and what it means for women’s boxing.
Table of Contents
A Historic Rivalry Comes to a Close
Katie Taylor, Ireland’s undisputed super lightweight champion, and Amanda Serrano, Puerto Rico’s unified featherweight champion, have built one of the greatest rivalries in women’s boxing. Their first fight in April 2022 at Madison Square Garden was a landmark moment—the first women’s bout to headline the iconic venue. Taylor won that fight by a razor-thin split decision, earning Fight of the Year honors from Sports Illustrated. Their second clash in November 2024, part of the Jake Paul vs. Mike Tyson undercard, saw Taylor retain her titles with a controversial unanimous decision, despite Serrano landing a record 324 punches. The trilogy fight promised to settle the score, and it didn’t disappoint, even if the result stirred debate.
The stakes were high. Taylor, with a record of 24-1 and 6 KOs, was defending her undisputed junior welterweight titles. Serrano, at 47-3-1 with 31 KOs, aimed to flip the script and claim victory. The sold-out crowd, buzzing with Irish and Puerto Rican pride, knew they were witnessing history.
The Fight: A Tactical Masterclass
Unlike their previous slugfests, the trilogy bout was a more measured affair. Both fighters adopted a cautious approach, with Taylor boxing smartly from the outside, using her footwork to land crisp, accurate shots. Serrano, known for her relentless pressure, tried a different strategy, fighting at long range rather than pushing the pace inside. This shift led to a quieter fight, with only 140 punches landed compared to 541 in their second bout, according to CompuBox.
The early rounds were tight, with neither fighter dominating. Taylor’s counterpunching shone in rounds like the second and fourth, while Serrano landed a notable left hook in the third, causing a bruise under Taylor’s eye. By the later rounds, Taylor seemed to find her rhythm, particularly in rounds seven, nine, and ten, where her precision and movement gave her the edge. Serrano’s team believed she was ahead, but the judges saw it differently.
The Verdict: Taylor’s Triumph
When the final bell rang, the crowd awaited the scorecards with bated breath. Katie Taylor emerged victorious by majority decision, with scores of 97-93, 97-93, and 95-95, retaining her undisputed junior welterweight titles and completing a 3-0 sweep over Serrano. The decision wasn’t without controversy—some fans and analysts, including posts on X, felt Serrano’s aggression deserved more credit, with one user scoring it 95-95. Others, like @the_red_bull1, argued Taylor’s harder shots and control of key rounds made her the clear winner.
Serrano, gracious in defeat, acknowledged the historic night, saying, “Thank you, Katie Taylor, for an incredible 30 rounds.” Taylor praised their shared legacy, noting, “We’ve made history three times. It’s a privilege to share the ring with her.” Both ruled out a fourth fight, suggesting this was the end of their epic rivalry.
What’s Next for Women’s Boxing?
This trilogy has cemented Taylor and Serrano as giants of the sport. The all-women’s card, featuring five world title fights and 17 titles on the line, showcased the depth of talent in women’s boxing. Fighters like Alycia Baumgardner and Ellie Scotney also shone, proving the sport’s bright future. With Netflix’s global reach, the event reached millions, further elevating women’s boxing. Taylor, now 25-1, may look to new challenges, while Serrano, still a featherweight champion, remains a force. Their legacy, as Taylor said, is “embedded forever” in boxing history.
This fight wasn’t just about a winner—it was a celebration of resilience, skill, and progress. Katie Taylor walked away with the belts, but both fighters won the respect of the world.