Why Is Christian Pulisic Not Playing for the USA: Christian Pulisic, widely regarded as one of the best soccer players in U.S. history and affectionately nicknamed “Captain America,” has been notably absent from the U.S. Men’s National Team (USMNT) roster for the 2025 CONCACAF Gold Cup. This decision has sparked significant debate among fans, former players, and media, with opinions ranging from support for his choice to criticism over his commitment to the national team. So, why is Pulisic not playing for the USA, and what does this mean for the team as they prepare for the 2026 FIFA World Cup? Let’s dive into the reasons and the broader context.
Table of Contents
The Reason Behind Pulisic’s Absence
Christian Pulisic’s decision to sit out the 2025 Gold Cup stems primarily from the need for rest and recovery after an exhausting 2024–25 club season with AC Milan. The 26-year-old winger played 50 matches for his club, logging over 3,500 minutes and contributing 17 goals and 27 points across all competitions. This grueling schedule, combined with 14 appearances for the USMNT over the past two seasons, left Pulisic nursing minor injuries and physically depleted. In consultation with U.S. Soccer and head coach Mauricio Pochettino, Pulisic made the “collective decision” to prioritize his health to ensure peak performance for the 2026 World Cup, which the U.S. will co-host. U.S. Soccer sporting director Matt Crocker emphasized that this rest period is critical for Pulisic to be “fully prepared to perform at the highest level” next season and beyond.
Pulisic himself addressed the decision on CBS Sports’ Golazo America podcast, stating, “I had to make a decision, and this is what I feel is best for myself and, like I said, ultimately best for the team.” He also expressed a desire to participate in pre-Gold Cup friendlies against Turkey and Switzerland but was turned down by Pochettino, who preferred a consistent roster for the entire international window. This disagreement added fuel to the controversy, as some saw it as a lack of alignment between player and coach.
The Controversy and Criticism
Pulisic’s choice has not been without backlash. USMNT legends like Landon Donovan, Clint Dempsey, and Alexi Lalas publicly questioned his commitment. Donovan, in particular, took a subtle jab during a FOX Sports broadcast, comparing Pulisic’s absence to Cristiano Ronaldo’s dedication at age 40 in the UEFA Nations League. Donovan’s comments, which implied a lack of pride in representing the national team, prompted a response from Pulisic’s father, Mark, who highlighted Donovan’s own sabbatical in 2013. Pulisic himself called the criticism “way out of line,” emphasizing his 78 caps and 32 goals for the USMNT as evidence of his dedication.
The debate reflects broader tensions in American soccer. As more U.S. players like Pulisic compete at Europe’s top levels, the demanding club schedules often conflict with national team duties. Unlike major tournaments like the World Cup or Copa América, the Gold Cup is seen by some as less critical, leading players to prioritize rest. Other key USMNT players, including Antonee Robinson, Yunus Musah, and those participating in the Club World Cup, are also absent, raising concerns about team cohesion ahead of 2026.
Implications for the USMNT
Pulisic’s absence, coupled with the USMNT’s recent struggles—losses to Panama and Canada in the 2024 CONCACAF Nations League and friendlies against Turkey and Switzerland—has intensified scrutiny on the team. Pochettino, who took over in September 2024, faces pressure to build momentum for the World Cup. While the Gold Cup offers a chance to test younger players, the lack of star power could hinder preparation. However, some, like former USMNT midfielder Hugo Perez, argue that the World Cup’s importance will ensure Pulisic and others return fully committed.
Looking Ahead
Pulisic’s decision underscores the physical toll of modern soccer and the delicate balance between club and country. While his absence has sparked drama, it’s a strategic move to safeguard his health for the 2026 World Cup, where expectations for the USMNT are sky-high. As Pulisic noted, “People forget really quickly. Once I’m back with the national team and can play again, score a goal and win a game, people will forget all about this.” For now, the focus remains on supporting the current roster while anticipating Pulisic’s return.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Why did Christian Pulisic decide not to play in the 2025 Gold Cup?
Pulisic opted out to prioritize rest and recovery after a demanding season with AC Milan, where he played 50 matches and over 3,500 minutes. The decision was made in consultation with U.S. Soccer to ensure his readiness for the 2026 World Cup. - Did Mauricio Pochettino agree with Pulisic’s decision?
While Pochettino and U.S. Soccer supported Pulisic’s need for rest, he turned down Pulisic’s offer to play in friendlies before the Gold Cup, citing roster continuity. This led to some tension, as Pulisic wanted to contribute in a limited capacity. - What criticism has Pulisic faced for missing the Gold Cup?
Former USMNT players like Landon Donovan, Clint Dempsey, and Alexi Lalas criticized Pulisic, questioning his commitment to the national team. Donovan’s comments, comparing Pulisic to Ronaldo, sparked a notable feud, amplified by Pulisic’s father’s response. - How does Pulisic’s absence affect the USMNT’s World Cup preparation?
The absence of Pulisic and other key players may limit Pochettino’s ability to test his full roster, potentially impacting team cohesion. However, it provides opportunities for younger players to gain experience ahead of 2026. - Will Pulisic return to the USMNT soon?
Pulisic is expected to return for future USMNT camps, likely fully fit and motivated for the 2026 World Cup. He has expressed confidence that fans will move past the current controversy once he resumes playing.